If you’ve opened your renewal recently and thought, “Why did my homeowners insurance go up so much?”  you are definitely not alone.

Homeowners across Cape Coral, Fort Myers, and all of Southwest Florida have seen significant changes in their insurance premiums over the past few years. While it can feel frustrating, there are actually several very specific reasons why your rate may have increased.

Let’s break it down in a clear, practical way 👇

📈 1. The Age of Your Home (and Roof) Matters More Than Ever

One of the biggest drivers of your premium is the age of your home, especially your roof.

🔑 Why this matters:

• Older homes = higher risk of claims

• Older roofs = higher likelihood of wind and water damage

• Insurance companies price based on future risk, not past history

👉 In Southwest Florida, roofs are under heavy scrutiny due to hurricane exposure.

🌪️ 2. Expired Wind Mitigation Credits

This is something we see all the time with homeowners in Cape Coral and Fort Myers.

If you previously had a wind mitigation inspection, you likely received discounts for:

• Roof shape (hip roof)

• Secondary water resistance (SWR)

• Opening protection (impact windows/shutters)

🚨 The issue:

Wind mitigation reports typically expire after 5 years

If your report expired:

• You may have lost valuable discounts

• Your premium could jump significantly overnight

👉 Even if nothing about your home changed, your discounts may have disappeared

🏚️ 3. Older Roof = Higher Premium (or Fewer Options)

Insurance companies are becoming much stricter on roof age in Florida.

Common impacts:

• Roofs 10–15+ years old may see rate increases

• Roofs 15–20+ years old may:

  • Lose eligibility with preferred carriers

  • Be moved to higher-risk companies

  • Require inspections or replacement

👉 This is one of the #1 reasons we see premiums spike locally

📊 4. Claims History (Even Small Ones)

A lot of homeowners think:

“I only had one small claim it shouldn’t matter”

But here’s the reality 👇

• Claims can affect your insurance score

• Even non-catastrophic claims may:

  • Increase perceived risk

  • Limit carrier options

• Multiple claims in a short period = bigger impact

👉 While not always the main driver, claims can absolutely contribute to higher premiums

💳 5. Credit & Insurance Score Changes

Many people don’t realize this, but:

👉 Your credit history directly impacts your homeowners insurance rate

Insurance companies use an insurance score, which is influenced by:

• Payment history

• Credit utilization

• Length of credit history

If your score drops:

• Your premium can increase

• You may lose eligibility for preferred pricing

🌎 6. Florida Market Conditions (Big Picture)

Even if nothing about your home changed, your rate can still go up.

Why?

• Rising reinsurance costs

• Past hurricane losses

• Insurance companies tightening underwriting

• Fewer carriers = less competition

👉 This has been a major factor across all of Florida

🏗️ 7. Increased Replacement Costs

The cost to rebuild your home has gone up significantly due to:

• Labor shortages

• Material cost increases

• Inflation

Result:

• Higher dwelling coverage (Coverage A)

• Higher premiums to match

💡 8. Coverage Changes or Deductible Adjustments

Sometimes increases come from policy changes like:

• Lower deductibles

• Added endorsements

• Increased coverage limits

Even small tweaks can impact your premium more than expected.

📉 The GOOD News: Rates Are Starting to Stabilize

Now for the part most people don’t hear enough 👇

👉 There is positive movement in the Florida insurance market

We are starting to see:

• New companies entering Florida

• Increased competition

• Rate stabilization (and even decreases in some cases)

• More options for homeowners than we’ve seen in years

🏡 What this means for you:

• You may now qualify for better pricing

• Shopping your policy can actually make a BIG difference again

• Discounts (like wind mitigation) are more valuable than ever

✅ Final Thoughts

If your homeowners insurance went up, it’s usually not random—it’s driven by:

• Roof age

• Expired wind mitigation discounts

• Market conditions

• Credit and insurance scoring

• Replacement cost increases

The key is understanding what specifically caused YOUR increase—because in many cases, there are ways to bring it back down.

💰 Want to See If You Can Save?

If you want to save money on your homeowners insurance,
👉 click here to get a quote

At Wilcox Family Insurance, we shop multiple companies to find the best fit for your home—while still keeping that personal, family-owned service you can trust.