Wilcox Family Insurance Company
Wilcox Family Insurance: A Legacy of Trust & Care
Founded by our father, David Wilcox, Wilcox Family Insurance has grown into one of the largest independent homeowner’s insurance agencies in Southwest Florida. Based out of Fort Myers, FL and proudly serving Fort Myers, Cape Coral, Naples, and the broader South Florida region, our family-owned firm delivers personalized insurance coupled with exceptional service. His vision to create a family centric insurance experience has been the driving force steering our office to where it is today. Specializing in homeowners’ insurance, he wanted to found an agency that can offer all of the options in regards to companies to choose from like many corporate powerhouse agencies but still maintain the intimate experience of a mom-and-pops business. At Wilcox Family Insurance, not only can we find you the best coverage at the best price. But more importantly, we treat our customers like family.
👨👩👧👦 Family at the Core
Today, siblings Jessica Williams and Mark Wilcox—both proud owners—steer the day-to-day operations alongside a friendly, non commissioned team. Both were raised in Cape Coral and still call the growing city home. Together, they uphold the values of helpfulness, integrity, and being “the good guys,” ensuring each client feels truly like they are part of the family. They were molded by the founder and literal father of Wilcox Family Insurance, David Wilcox. With his mentorship they now continue his legacy of navigating the ever-changing landscape of Florida’s insurance industry to provide protection for our clients from life’s twist and turns. One of the greatest virtues that David has passed on is his value of family. Family has always been the most important thing to him and why he chose to start a family operated office. With this valuable mindset Jessica and Mark do their best to continue this legacy and look forward to passing this on to future generations of agents.
What We Stand For
- Independence that benefits you: As an independent agency, we work for our customers—not one insurance company. That means we shop coverage options across carriers to find the best fit in price and protection.
- Impressive track record: With over 25 years in the insurance industry and an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau and Trusted Choice, we’ve earned the trust of hundreds of five star reviews and thousands of loyal clients
Where We Serve & What We Offer
Operating from Fort Myers—with strong reach into Cape Coral and all of South Florida—we offer comprehensive coverage across personal and business lines.
From homeowners insurance, auto insurance, condo insurance, boat insurance, and motorcycle insurance to the more specialized mobile home insurance, recreational vehicle insurance, and flood insurance/hurricane insurance coverage, we tailor solutions to your unique circumstances.
For business clients, we provide commercial auto insurance, property insurance, general liability insurance, workers’ compensation insurance, and group health insurance. And our personal coverage lineup also includes life insurance, umbrella insurance, and Medicare plans.
Trusted Partners—Top Rated Carriers
We’ve built relationships with leading insurance carriers to ensure strong coverage and competitive pricing. Our featured carriers include Progressive, Travelers, Geico, Kemper, American Integrity, Universal, Homeowners Choice, Security First, and many more.
Rated for Service & Care
Customer testimonials speak volumes:
- “Always prompt, courteous and professional. Other agencies should take note! They truly treat me like family!” – Francine Fantuzzo
- “Jessica is an excellent in person representative. She came across as very personable & desiring to be of help. She accomplished that in a very efficient & pleasant way. Jessica should be recognized by Wilcox for her outstanding performance.” – Bill Foster
- “This is such a great company! They always answer and help with any questions and they are very polite unlike some insurance companies I have called in the past.” – Courtney Curtis
- “Great customer service, they go the extra mile. I almost made a grave mistake with my policy and they caught it.” – Loren Harrington
- “Very helpful in major claim and ease of communication” – Bob & Pam Leader
Ready When You Are
Whether it’s an instant homeowners quote, a tailored auto plan, or complete business coverage, getting started is easy. You can request quotes online, call us at 239-337-7755, or visit us in Fort Myers. We’re here to guide you every step of the way.